Analysis of Legal Nature of Bank Guarantees in the Light of the Principles of Autonomy and Strict Compliance

Authors

  • Nino Lipartia

Keywords:

Guarantee, autonomous nature, public procurement, security mean, guarantor, principal, beneficiary, demand, demand presentation period, principle of “strict compliance”, correct management of claim, advance security guarantee, contract fulfilment guarante

Abstract

The Civil Code of Georgia contains rules regulating relationship originating from the means of security of a creditor’s demand. These means are can be found in different chapters of the Code, according to their legal nature.

A bank guarantee is one of the means of demand security, where a guarantor undertakes to pay the amount and satisfy creditor’s demand if the debtor breaches his liabilities. It is regarded as one of the quick and efficient means of satisfaction of creditor’s demand. A bank guarantee, as a demand security appeared on the local market of the USA in mid-1960s, however it has been widely used in the international banking practice since 1970s.

The institute of bank guarantee is widely used both in international trade and economic relationships and at national level. It is associated with the fulfilment of both pecuniary and non-pecuniary liabilities. Guarantee is used to secure such contractual relationships, that are related to provision of goods or construction services.

The bank guarantees, together with documentary letters of credit, constitute the main elements of modern commercial relationships. Due to the intensity of its application in international trade relationships and the problems arising with regard to regulation, along domestic legal law it is regulated on the basis of the Uniform Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce and the Convention on Independent Guarantees and Stand-by Letters of Credit (hereinafter the Convention), adopted by the United National Commission on International Trade.

Despite diverse regulation, a bank guarantee has a very complex nature. Furthermore, it is both necessary and mandatory to correctly administer the demand, deriving from the bank guarantee as the existence of the rights and obligations to the parties to the relationship are directly related thereto. Such complexity of relationships gives rise to many problems in practice. The parties to an agreement are not able to fully exercise their rights, administer demands and protect their rights, what in most cases, results in a dispute.

The problems related to bank guarantee are quite abundant in Georgian reality as well. Their abundance was conditioned by the introduction of bank guarantees in public procurement relationships and their increased number.

The paper offers analysis of the legal nature of a bank guarantee and its basic principles, whose role in the administration of demands originating from bank guarantees is of paramount importance.

References

Civil Code of Georgia, Law of Georgia, 26/06/2017, Articles 881, 887, 885.

Convention of Independent Guarantees and Stand-by letters, Articles 2, 3, 5, 12, 14, 16.

International Chamber of Commerce, Uniform Rules of Independent Guarantees #458, Articles N1, 2, 9.

International Chamber of Commerce, Uniform Rules of Independent Guarantees #758, Articles N3, 13, 14, 15, 19, 22, 20, 6.

Barru D.J., How to Guarantee Contractor Performance on International Construction Projects: Comparing

Surety Bonds with Bank Guarantees and Standby Letters of Credit, George Washington International Law Review, Vol. 37, Issue 1, 2005, 78-80.

Barru D.J., How to Guarantee Contractor Performance on International Construction Projects: Comparing Surety Bonds with Bank Guarantees and Standby Letters of Credit, George Washington International Law Review, 2005, 74-75.

Bertrams R., Bank Guarantees in International Trade, 3rd ed., Kluwer Law International, 2004, 1.

Chanturia L., Commentary of Civil Code of Georgia, (Edit), Tbilisi, 2017, 28, 57, (In Georgian).

Chanturia L., Credit Assurance Law, Tbilisi, 2012, 204 (In Georgian).

Chanturia L,. The General part of Civil law, Tbilisi, 2011, Tbilisi, 90 (In Georgian).

De Ly P., The UN Convention on Independent Guarantees and Stand-by letters of Credit” 1999, 831.

Dolan J.F., The UN Convention on International Independent Undertakings: Do States with Mature Letter-ofCredit Regimes Need it”, Banking and Finance Law Review, 1998, 13.

Eitelber E., Autonomy of document Credit Undertakings in South African Law, 2002, 122.

Elliot F., Project Security: Bonds and Guarantees, https://www.fenwickelliott.com/sites/default/files/ nick_gould_-_project_security_bonds_and_gurantees_paper_for_university_of_vienna.indd_.pdf, 10, [15/07/2017].

Enonchong N., The Autonomy Principle of Letter of Credit: an Illegality Exception? Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, 2006, 404.

Goode R., Abstract Payment Undertakings and the Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce, Saint Louis university Law Journal, 1995, 740.

Goode R., Commercial Law, 1026, Jack r. Documentary Credits, 2001, 366.

Goode R., Guide to the ICC Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees, 1992, 751.

Hein online, Citation: 9 Const. L. Int’l 13 2014. The usage of on-demand bonds has become more prevalent and calls more frequent, 2014,17., Citation: 9 Const. L. Int’l 13 2014, [10/12/2016].

Hsun Ch.H., The Independence of Demand Guarantees, Performance Bonds and Standby Letters of Credit,” National Taiwan University Law Review, Vol. 1:2, 2006, 3.

Kayembe G.L., The Fraud Exception in Bank Guarantee”, 2008, 1.

Kelly-Louw M., Limiting Exceptions to The Autonomy Principle of Demand Guarantees and Letters of Credit, 2008,197, 311.

Kelly-Louw M., Selective legal Aspects of bank Guarantees, 2008, 126.

Kelly-Louw M., The Documentary Nature of Demand Guarantee and Doctrine of Strict Compliance , 2009, 309.

Kelly-Louw M., The Documentary Nature of Demand Guarantees and the Doctrine of Strict Compliance, (part 2) 2009, 301 478, 481.

Khatiashvili A., Bank Guarantee as an Independent Security for the Fulfilment of obligation and liability of the parties to the contract, 2011, 35, 36, 37, (In Georgian).

Khotenashvili P., Legal Aspects of Bank Guarantees, 2015, Tbilisi, 7, (In Georgian).

Michelle K.L., Selective Legal Aspects of Bank Demand Guarantees, University of South Africa, 2008, 65.

Mofleh A.I. Abstract Payment Undertaking: To What Extent are They Truly Abstract?, Uni, Versity of Leicester, 2009, 10,11,12.

Odeke A., Judicial Approach to Injunctions in Letters of Credit and Performance Bond Transactions: The Fraud Exception Re-examined, Denning Law Journal, Vol. 10,1995, 38.

Oelofse A., The Law of Documentary Letters of Credit in Comparative Perspective, 1997, 354.

Popkhadze G., The Legal Nature of Bank Guarantee, 2016, 8, (In Georgian).

Pugh-Thomas A., Letters of Credit –Injunctions-the Purist and the Pragmatist: Can a Buyer Bypass the Guarantor and Stop the Seller from Demand Payment from the Guarantor? 1996, 210.

Seaconsar Far East Ltd v Bank Markazi Jomhouri Islami Iran: HL 15 Oct 1993.

Decision of Gurjaani District Court of December 27, 2016, №340110015001160711.

Decision of Khashuri District court, September 29, 2015, Case №2-302-2015, №130210015001063580.

Decision of The Supreme court of Georgia , Chamber of Civil, Industrial and Bankruptcy October 20, 2009, Case № ას-562-871-09.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Georgia Chamber of civil Cases, 07 July, 2012, Case, №AS-80-77-2014.

Decision of The Supreme court of Georgia, Chamber of Civil, Industrial and Bankruptcy March 17, 2009, Case №AS-781-996-08.

Decision of The Supreme court of Georgia, Chamber of Civil, Industrial and Bankruptcy January 20, 2001, Case №3კ-62-01 17.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Georgia, dated July 11, 2017, Case №AS-2ბ7114/14, №330210014403740.

Decision of the Tbilisi Appeals Court of April 10, 2017 №2B/4510-16.

Decision of the Tbilisi Appeals Court of February 10, 2016, №2B/5563-15, №130210015001063580.

Decision of the Tbilisi Appeals Court of November 09, 2016, №2B/4559-15, №330210015703697.

Decision of the Tbilisi City Court of July 17, 2015, Case №2/856-15.

Decision of the Tbilisi City Court of June 21, 2016, Case №2/7526-15.

Published

2017-12-31

How to Cite

Lipartia, N. (2017). Analysis of Legal Nature of Bank Guarantees in the Light of the Principles of Autonomy and Strict Compliance. Journal of Law, (2). Retrieved from https://jlaw.tsu.ge/index.php/JLaw/article/view/2378

Issue

Section

Articles